Derek Jeter vs Sandy Koufax: Who Wins on MLB Stats?

**Statistical Breakdown:** This comparison is fundamentally flawed because we're measuring a hitter against a pitcher using only offensive metrics. Jeter's 3,465 hits, .310 average, and .817 OPS across 2,747 games showcase remarkable longevity and consistent production. Meanwhile, Koufax's offensive stats are irrelevant since he pitched in only 397 games over 12 seasons. The "category wins" system here is meaningless when comparing apples to oranges.

**Signature Strengths:** Jeter's calling card was clutch hitting and postseason heroics, batting .308 in 158 playoff games while capturing five World Series rings. His leadership and ability to elevate his game when it mattered most defined his Hall of Fame career. Koufax, conversely, was pure pitching dominance—a 2.76 ERA, three Cy Young Awards, and four no-hitters including a perfect game. His final four seasons were otherworldly: a 1.86 ERA with 1,228 strikeouts in 1,377 innings.

**Final Verdict:** Peak dominance trumps longevity when the peak is this transcendent. Koufax revolutionized pitching and retired as the game's most feared hurler, while Jeter, though excellent, was never the absolute best at his position during any single season. **Sandy Koufax is the superior player.**